United Nations University Institute for Water, Environment and Health, Hamilton, Canada
Increasingly expensive to maintain, experts foresee a trend to decommissioning dams
By 2050, most people on Earth will live downstream of tens of thousands of large dams built in the 20th century, many of them already operating at or beyond their design life, according to a UN University analysis.
The report, “Ageing water infrastructure: An emerging global risk,” by UNU’s Canadian-based Institute for Water, Environment and Health, says most of the 58,700 large dams worldwide were constructed between 1930 and 1970 with a design life of 50 to 100 years, adding that at 50 years a large concrete dam “would most probably begin to express signs of aging.”
Ageing signs include increasing cases of dam failures, progressively increasing costs of dam repair and maintenance, increasing reservoir sedimentation, and loss of a dam’s functionality and effectiveness, “strongly interconnected” manifestations, the paper says.
The report says dams that are well designed, constructed and maintained can “easily” reach 100 years of service but predicts an increase in “decommissioning” — a phenomenon gaining pace in the USA and Europe — as economic and practical limitations prevent ageing dams from being upgraded or if their original use is now obsolete.
Worldwide, the huge volume of water stored behind large dams is estimated at 7,000 to 8,300 cubic kilometres — enough to cover about 80% of Canada’s landmass under a meter of water.
The report provides an overview of dam ageing by world region and primary function — water supply, irrigation, flood control, hydropower, and recreation.
It also details the increasing risk of older dams, the rising maintenance expense, the declining functionality due to sedimentation, the benefits of restoring or redesigning natural environments, and the societal impacts — pro and con — that need to be weighed by policymakers deciding what to do. Notably, “the nature of these impacts varies significantly between low- and high-income countries.”
The analysis also includes dam decommissioning or ageing case studies from the USA, France, Canada, India, Japan, and Zambia & Zimbabwe.
Climate change will accelerate the dam ageing process
“This report aims to attract global attention to the creeping issue of ageing water storage infrastructure and stimulate international efforts to deal with this emerging, rising water risk,” says co-author Vladimir Smakhtin, Director of UNU-INWEH.
“Underlined is the fact that the rising frequency and severity of flooding and other extreme environmental events can overwhelm a dam’s design limits and accelerate a dam’s ageing process. Decisions about decommissioning, therefore, need to be taken in the context of a changing climate.”
Notes lead author and UNU-INWEH Senior Researcher Duminda Perera: “This problem of ageing large dams today confronts a relatively small number of countries — 93% of all the world’s large dams are located in just 25 nations.”
“Large dam construction surged in the mid-20th century and peaked in the 1960s – 70s,” he says, “especially in Asia, Europe and North America, while in Africa the peak occurred in the 1980s. The number of newly-constructed large dams after that continuously and progressively declined.”
According to the report, the world is unlikely to witness another large dam-building revolution as in the mid-20th century, but dams constructed then will inevitably be showing their age.
China has 23,841 large dams (40% of the world’s total). And 32,716 large dams (55% of the world’s total) are found in just four Asian countries: China, India, Japan, and the Republic of Korea — a majority of which will reach the 50-year threshold relatively soon. The same is true of many large dams in Africa, South America, and Eastern Europe.
The pace of large dam construction has dropped dramatically in the last four decades and continues to decline in part because “the best locations for such dams globally have been progressively diminishing as nearly 50% of global river volume is already fragmented or regulated by dams,” the report says.
As well, there are strong concerns regarding the environmental and social impacts of dams, and large dams in particular, as well as emerging ideas and practices on the alternative types of water storage, nature-based solutions, and types of energy production beyond hydropower.
Drivers of dam decommissioning
Public safety, escalating maintenance costs, reservoir sedimentation, and restoration of a natural river ecosystem are among the reasons driving dam decommissioning.
However, most dams removed to date have been small; decommissioning large dams (defined by ICOLD as 15 or more metres from lowest foundation to crest, or 5 to 15 metres impounding more than 3 million cubic metres) is “still in its infancy, with only a few known cases in the last decade.”
“A few case studies of ageing and decommissioned large dams illustrate the complexity and length of the process that is often necessary to orchestrate the dam removal safely,” adds co-author and UNU-INWEH Adjunct Professor R. Allen Curry, based at the University of New Brunswick.
“Even removing a small dam requires years (often decades) of continuous expert and public involvement, and lengthy regulatory reviews. With the mass ageing of dams well underway, it is important to develop a framework of protocols that will guide and accelerate the dam removal process.”
Decommissioning will also have various positive and negative economic, social, and ecological impacts to be considered in a local and regional social, economic, and geographic context “critical to protect the broader, sustainable development objectives for a region,” the report says.
“Overall, dam decommissioning should be seen as equally important as dam building in the overall planning process on water storage infrastructure developments.”
“Ultimately, value judgments will determine the fate of many of these large water storage structures. It is not an easy process, and thus distilling lessons from and sharing dam decommissioning experiences should be a common global goal. Lack of such knowledge and lack of its reflection in relevant regional/national policies/practices may progressively and adversely affect the ability to manage water storage infrastructure properly as it is ageing.”
###
In addition to the three UNU-INWEH experts, the report was co-authored by Spencer Williams, Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies, Geneva, Switzerland. and Taylor North of McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada.
The report is available post-embargo at http://bit.ly/UNU-dams
By the numbers
General
58,700: large dams registered in the International Commission on Large Dams (ICOLD) database, a large dam is defined as 15+ metres in height, measured from lowest foundation to crest, or 5 to 15 metres high impounding more than 3 million cubic metres (0.003 km3). Within the 58,700 large dam total, roughly one in eight has a 100 million cubic metre (0.1 km3) capacity
7,000 to 8,300 km3: volume of water stored behind large dams worldwide — about one-sixth of all river discharge worldwide each year — enough to cover roughly 80% of Canada’s landmass under a meter of water
50 to 100 years: design life of dams constructed between 1930 and 1970 (when most existing large dams were built). Average life expectancy: 50 years
~16,000: large dams 50 to 100 years old in North America and Asia
~2,300: large dams 100+ years old in North America and Asia
USA / Canada
56: average age of 90,580 US dams (all sizes)
85%+: US dams in 2020 operating at or beyond their life expectancy
75%: US dam failures that occurred after 50 years of age
US$ 64 billion: estimated cost to refurbish US dams
1,275: dams removed in 21 US states in the last 30 years; 80 removed in 2017 alone
50%+: large dams in Canada over 50 years old
Asia / Pacific
China
56%: proportion of the world’s large dams located in China and the US (the top 25 countries account for more than ~93%)
23,841: large dams in China (the most of any country, and 40% of the world’s total
60%: proportion of the world’s large dams in Asia
55%: proportion of the world’s large dams in just four countries — China, India, Japan, and the Republic of Korea — the majority of which will soon reach 50 years of age
India
1,115+: large dams in India that will be roughly 50 years old in 2025
4,250+: large dams in India that will be 50+ years old in 2050
64: large dams in India that will be 150+ years old in 2050
3.5 million: the approximate number of people at risk if India’s Mullaperiyar dam, built 100+ years ago, were to fail. The dam, in a seismically active area, shows significant structural flaws and its management is a contentious issue between Kerala and Tamil Nadu States
Japan
100+ years: average age of large dams in Japan
Australia
650: large dams in Australia, half of them 50+ years old; 50+ have been in operation for 100+ years. Portion of Australia’s clean energy generated from hydropower: 65%
UK / Europe
100+ years: average age of large dams in the UK
~10%: large dams in Europe 100+ years old
Africa
2,000: large dams in Africa (¼ of them in South Africa), the fewest of any continent; mostly used for irrigation
UNU-INWEH (inweh.unu.edu) is supported by the Government of Canada through Global Affairs Canada, and hosted by McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada
UNU-INWEH’s Water Learning Centre (http://bit.ly/wlc-unu-inweh) offers free courses to university students and practicing water professionals looking to strengthen their capacity in several focused and multidisciplinary learning areas.
Coverage highlights
Agence France Presse, France
World’s aging big dams pose ’emerging risk’: UN
https://www.ctvnews.ca/climate-and-environment/world-s-aging-big-dams-pose-emerging-risk-un-1.5278178
French version: La vétusté des barrages fluviaux est un risque émergent, estime l’ONU
https://actu.orange.fr/societe/environnement/la-vetuste-des-barrages-fluviaux-est-un-risque-emergent-estime-l-onu-CNT000001wAWEn.html
Agencia EFE, Spain
El envejecimiento de miles de grandes embalses es un creciente problema mundial
https://www.infobae.com/america/agencias/2021/01/22/el-envejecimiento-de-miles-de-grandes-embalses-es-un-creciente-problema-mundial/
Europa Press, Spain
La mayor parte de la Humanidad vivirá amenazada por viejas presas para 2050
https://www.europapress.es/ciencia/habitat/noticia-mayor-parte-humanidad-vivira-amenazada-viejas-presas-2050-20210122180412.html
Press Trust of India
Ageing dams in India, US, other nations pose growing threat: UN report
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/ageing-dams-in-india-us-other-nations-pose-growing-threat-un-report/articleshow/80433078.cms
Agenzia Giornalistica Italia, Italy
Le dighe invecchiano, allarme dell’Onu sulla manutenzione
https://www.agi.it/estero/news/2021-01-24/clima-dighe-invecchiano-e-urge-manutenzione-allarme-onu-11137456
SINC (Spanish Scientific News Agency), Spain
Las presas envejecidas se convierten en una amenaza creciente
https://www.virtualpro.co/noticias/las-presas-envejecidas-se-convierten-en-una-amenaza-creciente
Indo-Asian News Service (IANS), India
Ageing, unsafe dams growing threat in India too: UN report
https://www.nationalheraldindia.com/environment/ageing-unsafe-dams-growing-threat-in-india-too-un-report
News sites
Guardian, UK
UN warns most will live downstream of ageing large dams by 2050
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/jan/22/un-warns-most-will-live-downstream-ageing-large-dams-2050
Daily Mail, UK
Most of the world’s 58,000 biggest dams are crumbling, report warns
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-9176301/Most-worlds-58-000-biggest-dams-crumbling-report-warns.html
China Global Television Network (CGTN)
Aging dams pose grave threat as climate change tests their strength
https://news.cgtn.com/news/2021-01-22/Aging-dams-pose-grave-threat-as-climate-change-tests-their-strength-Xb7uC5mNKU/index.html
Kompas, Indonesia
Puluhan Ribu Bendungan Besar Dunia Mulai Menua, Apa Dampaknya?
https://www.kompas.com/tren/read/2021/01/24/123000265/puluhan-ribu-bendungan-besar-dunia-mulai-menua-apa-dampaknya-
ReliefWeb (UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs), United States
Ageing Water Storage Infrastructure: An Emerging Global Risk
https://reliefweb.int/report/world/ageing-water-storage-infrastructure-emerging-global-risk
Clarín, Argentina
Próximo peligro para la humanidad: los 60.000 viejos embalses que hay en el mundo
https://www.clarin.com/viste/proximo-peligro-humanidad-60-000-viejos-embalses-mundo_0_w2tvUidTf.html
Eco-Business, Singapore
Retiring ageing hydropower dams could protect people and budgets. But aren’t they needed in the energy transition?
https://www.eco-business.com/news/retiring-ageing-hydropower-dams-could-protect-people-and-budgets-but-arent-they-needed-in-the-energy-transition/
Radio France International
Online: Are Africa’s Ageing Dams Doomed?
https://www.modernghana.com/news/1057391/are-africas-ageing-dams-doomed.html
Audio: https://www.rfi.fr/en/africa/20210125-are-africa-s-ageing-dams-doomed-united-nations-water-environment-health-safety-report
News release in full, click here
Coverage summary, click here